Shakes & Drinks
Hand-spun shakes, fresh-squeezed lemonades, local craft sodas and drip coffee. Plus a cookie the size of your face.
Something to wash it down
Shakes are spun from vanilla custard made by a dairy in Wilmington, Ohio, thick enough to stand a straw in. The Buckeye, peanut butter and chocolate fudge, has outsold every other flavor since the day it launched.
Lemonades are squeezed in the shop every morning, never from concentrate. We also carry Cincinnati-brewed craft sodas and a rotating cold brew from a local roaster.
Local sodas
Craft sodas brewed less than three miles from our Vine Street shop.
Real fruit
Strawberry basil and mango lemonades use fresh puree, not syrup.
Dairy-free options
Oat milk shakes available with vanilla or chocolate custard-style base.
On the board
6 items. Calories are for the sandwich as listed, without sides.
Buckeye ShakeFan favorite
$7.25Vanilla custard, peanut butter, chocolate fudge, crushed peanut butter cups.
Black Raspberry Chip
$7.25Black raspberry swirl, dark chocolate chips, whipped cream.
Fresh LemonadeFan favorite
$3.95Squeezed daily. Classic, strawberry basil or spicy mango.
Local Craft Soda
$3.25Root beer, black cherry, ginger ale or cream soda, brewed in Cincinnati.
Cold Brew
$4.5016 oz, steeped 18 hours, oat milk available.
The Big CookieFan favorite
$3.75Brown butter chocolate chunk with flaky salt, 6 inches across.
How we build it
- 1
Custard base
Vanilla frozen custard from a family dairy 50 miles north.
- 2
Spun to order
Mix-ins are folded in by hand so they stay chunky.
- 3
Squeezed daily
About 400 lemons a day across all four shops.
- 4
Baked at 2 pm
Cookies come out warm for the afternoon crowd.
Add-ons and combos
| Add-on | Details | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Make it a malt | Classic malted milk powder | +$0.75 |
| Oat milk base | Dairy-free shake base | +$1.25 |
| Extra shot of cold brew | In any shake or coffee | +$1.00 |
| Half-dozen Big Cookies | Boxed for sharing | $19.50 |
Prices shown are for pickup and dine-in. Third-party delivery apps set their own prices.
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry shakes contain no gluten ingredients. The Buckeye contains peanut butter cups, which may contain wheat traces.
Our Over-the-Rhine and Covington shops pour four local draft beers after 11 am. Oakley and Northside serve non-alcoholic drinks only.
Yes, shakes travel well for about 20 minutes. We pack them in insulated sleeves.